Jackie Treehorn. Because Jackie Treehorn treats objects like women... man.
Lifestyle
Fallout v. Deadspace
I'm making a few assumptions in my answer that I think you'll find acceptable. 1) I'm assuming that second game is Deadspace, grotesque alien horror, really violent. Yeah. 2) I'm assuming that this is a no extra-life no save and replay situation. I die, i die. 3) I'm assuming that this is a real life representation of these worlds. Living in them as if they were reality as the developers imagined them.
That said, 24 hours in Deadspace. I'll take my chances. And let me be clear, my chances of survival are next to nothing, but if I do survive my necromorph disaster, there are parts of the Deadspace universe where life continues essentially normally. Even a high-tech enjoyable life of luxury in a futuristic society. Those are not the experiences of protagonist Isaac Clark, but I could hope that I could maneuver my way around the terrifying man-hunting alien virus and evil cultists and find a spaceship to something better. If not, 24 hours might be plausible to wait it out.
It would be far easier to survive the Fallout universe but less enjoyable to do so and not for eight fucking years. Christ, it's still a total post-apocalyptic wasteland infested with radioactive scorpions the size of buses, fire breathing ants, mutants who carry sledgehammers and say things like, "I will wear your bones around my neck," and cannibals. Something would get me eventually. And even if it didn't, life for those years would be terrible.
Plus the girls in the Deadspace universe seem more attractive. Well... at least until they sprout an extra row of teeth and tentacular razor swords from their shoulder blades.
Food v. Food
Your question is a little confusing because I'm allowed to have the foods prepared some ways but not others. For example fried chicken would need to be battered and maybe breaded. Can I have any amount of flour without flour being one of my ingredients? What about bread crumbs? If I can have bread crumbs, do I automatically get bread?
Assuming that the question is about choosing five key ingredients and discludes dessert, (with sugar, flour, cream, and eggs you can make a ton of amazing stuff) here is my list.
Chicken
Steak (which could be ground into ground beef)
Potatoes
Cheese
Lobster
With that and spices - I'd only be really really really sad... not suicidal.
Zorg v. Ruby Rod
Ruby Rod on weekends. He'd get pretty annoying but I could tolerate it in short bursts and my weekends would be interesting. I'd be worried Zorg would want me to do some contract killing or off me for my general dislike of authority. Plus there's the whole "allies with a planet consuming evil" thing that might get in the way of us just casually hanging out.
Why not Lilu? I feel like the fifth element would be would be kind of into me.
East v. West
I would choose Dan Smith - lame as that may be, do you really want your name to be a joke? If I had to choose one of the ridiculous names then I would go with either Leoz Maxwell Jilliumz because they could call me Leo and it’s a great name or I'd go with Swirvithan L'Goodling-Splatt because it’s the best. In that last case I'd request everyone calls me by my full name at all times. I would not respond to just Swirvithan.
House v. Season Tickets
House. I want to live by the water in peace. And even if I had the tickets, Cleveland teams would still lose. Both would be nice though.
Ice Cream v. Beer
Ice cream. Assuming that you mean I have to decide between giving up ice cream forever versus giving up beer forever, but with the rest of my diet remaining unaffected, I would give up beer. I like ice cream more. Though not much more.
If you mean that I'm only allowed to consume all ice cream or all beer then I also choose ice cream. Both options would likely lead to my imminent death, but ice cream would be slower and I might survive if I was allowed to have all ranges of exotic favors. This ice cream has steak in it and green beans!
Costner v. Crowe
I don't know about the personalities of either man, but the just based on the movies each is in I think I have more similar tastes and sensibilities to Crowe. Also Crowe is perhaps a bit more successful, which has more tangible monetary rewards. With regard to who would be the better father, it's a toss up. They both seem like stern yet compassionate men who would encourage success from their children. At no slight to my own father, they both seem fine choices.